User blog comment:Mikel6718/Give Yourself Goosebumps/@comment-2170890-20191005134013

Attack of the Beastly Babysitter was my favorite back in the day, but it's all accounting for taste of course. I'm lucky enough to have all of them, so one day I might have a think and see if I can list what I consider to be the best out of all of them, but that's my recommendation for now.

I would agree with the below choices as well, but admittedly have to refamiliarize myself with All Day Nightmare, but I remember enjoying it (mostly the werewolf stuff, because I'm biased.)