User blog comment:NicktheDummy/Tips for Goosebumps: The Game/@comment-24309486-20160719042859/@comment-26862374-20160719160326

There's actually no telling, but when you die, the one alseep is in a different place, I know this because one time it was in the center, then when I replayed, it was on the right. Just keep picking, you'll get it right eventually