Mirror Mirror on the Wall

Story 9 out of 10 featured in, "More and More Tales to give you Goosebumps".

Plot
Bonnie Sue Bowers is the most beautiful girl alive. According to herself anyway, as she happens to be her biggest fan! She even has a list of why she's the most beautiful girl alive, or at least used to be:
 * 1) Her thick, wavy blonde hair
 * 2) blue eyes to die for
 * 3) the sweetest button nose
 * 4) baby soft skin
 * 5) the straightest, whitest teeth

Bonnie reveals that she's not pretty anymore, and it's all because of her reflection!

Bonnie's reflection had grown so tired of her looking at herself all day that she began rebelling, at one point reaching out of the mirror and pinching her. Eventually the reflection came right out of the mirror and tried to shove the real Bonnie Sue into the mirror. Bonnie smashes the mirror though and it shatters into a thousand pieces.

From the shards rise more and more Bonnies, she then takes out her compact mirror in her pocket and it sucks up all of the miniture Bonnies.

However, a few days after that, Bonnie goes to try out hairstyles in the mirror and is pulled inside and traded with her reflection. So now she spends her time waiting for a chance to escape, especially since Reflection Bonnie doesn't take care of herself and dresses like a slob!