The Scarecrow

The Scarecrow is a story featured in one of the Tales To Give You Goosebumps books.

Plot
One day, a Magical scarecrow appears randomly in a neighbors yard. It has three, very expensive accessories that each appeal to three friends: A handsome scarf, a baseball cap, and leather gloves. One by one the three friends each decide to steal the item they want.

But unknown to them, they are about to learn the consequences for stealing...

The girl, who adored the scarf comes down with a sore throat and she eventually loses her voice. The boy who steals the cap suddenly acts as though he had a concussion.

When the final girl attempts to swipe the leather gloves, her two friends pop up behind her and admit they faked the whole thing to scare her.

It's then the Scarecrow smiles...